The Mystery of the Lady Carfax Recording

In the Hobbs-Shelly group there are two Lady Carfax recordings. My question is are both recordings Hobbs and Shelly?  In the one I posted  the actors  sound different.  The scripts are similar but not exact. Can someone shed some light on the mystery?

196005030005SherlockHolmes5283HobbsShellyTheDisappearanceOfLadyFrancesCarfax24m49s.mp3

You need to be a member of Times Past to add comments!

Join Times Past

Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • 2309842481?profile=originalThe first one you uploaded above with the shorter title is from the Robert Hardy & Nigel Stock Caedmon vinyl releases. So the date is wrong.

    Before I came to this group I'd download these from many sources and for every source they had a wrong Blue Carbuncle. It would always be the right story but from the Gielgud broadcasts. It wasn't until I joined here that I came across the correct Blue Carbuncle.

This reply was deleted.