What do you think is the scariest OTR?

[Paul Dickey]

One of my all time Scariest OTRs is Quiet Please "The Thing on the Fourble Board. Whats yours?

[TheMadBlonde]

I've never heard of this so am very excited to have a chance to listen to something recommended as being seriously scary. I do enjoy my thrills. Thanks for sharing!

[Mike Newton]

The Vengeful Corpse, a 1949 Inner Sanctum mystery which told of how a young woman became possessed by the spirit of an old witch from Salem, Mass. It was one of the first shows in my collection that I got from a friend who used to do big band remotes for Duke Ellington. In those days, you had the shows on reel to reel tape or cassette. My friend had a large collection from which I would make my selections and then he would "cue" up the tape to transfer it to a cassette. I recall this particular show because at one point, the young woman screams when the witch enters her body. I was listening to it when my wife came in behind me, and gave out with a maniacal cackle. I jumped about a foot. I remember fondly because it was from that era that I woud have been listening to it, under the blankets.

[Dave Miller]

I have to agree with you, Paul, about "The Thing on the Fourble Board" being the scariest otr for me. The sound effects of the creature was just about the creepiest thing I ever heard. My hair, what's left of it that is, is just now settling down."The City of the Dead" on Adventures By Morse had some eerie moments too, but nothing like "The Thing..." did.

[Frank Hablawi]

This was an amazing story - very Lovecraftian and steeped in the unexplained!

I'll have to search for my favorite scary otr and post it here. Thanks!